Opposition, Lawyers Oppose Judicial Age Extension

A growing chorus of opposition voices, senior lawyers and legal associations has emerged against a reported government proposal to extend the retirement age of judges serving in Sri Lanka’s Supreme Court and Court of Appeal.

What initially appeared to be a routine discussion on judicial tenure has rapidly evolved into a broader debate touching on constitutional governance, judicial independence and public confidence in the administration of justice.

According to reports circulating in the public domain, the proposal would require a constitutional amendment, as the retirement ages of superior court judges are currently fixed by the Constitution itself at 65 years for Supreme Court judges and 63 years for Court of Appeal judges.

The strongest criticism has come from the legal profession itself.

The Bar Association of Sri Lanka (BASL) has formally expressed what it described as “grave concern” over any attempt to alter the retirement age of sitting judges, warning that such a move could be perceived as interference with the judiciary and potentially damage public confidence in the rule of law. BASL has argued that no compelling necessity has been demonstrated for such a change and that altering constitutional provisions for a limited purpose risks creating a dangerous precedent for future governments.

Adding to the pressure, the Colombo High Court Lawyers’ Association has also written to President Anura Kumara Dissanayake expressing opposition to the proposal. The association warned that extending judicial tenure could freeze vacancies, delay promotions within the judicial service and undermine legitimate expectations among judges awaiting elevation to higher courts. The lawyers further argued that public confidence could be damaged if judges were seen to benefit from legislation affecting their own tenure.

The political opposition has seized upon the controversy.

The Samagi Jana Balawegaya (SJB) has publicly opposed the proposal, stating that the government has yet to adequately explain why such a constitutional change is required.

Opposition figures argue that any amendment touching judicial tenure must be approached with extreme caution because of the direct relationship between judicial independence and democratic governance.

Further criticism came from opposition parliamentarian Dayasiri Jayasekera, who questioned the timing and motivation behind the proposal.

He argued that extending the retirement age of serving judges could create perceptions of political influence and called for wider public scrutiny of the government’s intentions.

Supporters of the proposal, if any emerge formally, are likely to argue that experienced judges provide continuity, institutional memory and stability in complex constitutional and commercial matters.

However, opponents counter that Sri Lanka already possesses a substantial pool of qualified judicial officers, senior legal practitioners and officers from the Attorney General’s Department capable of filling vacancies as they arise.

At the heart of the debate lies a question larger than retirement ages themselves.

The controversy has become a test of how Sri Lanka balances the experience of senior judges against the constitutional principle that judicial appointments and tenure must remain free from even the perception of political influence.

Be that as it may, in matters involving the judiciary, perception often matters almost as much as reality.

For a country still rebuilding confidence in its institutions after years of political and constitutional turbulence, critics argue that any change affecting the nation’s highest courts must be supported by a compelling public interest rationale, not merely administrative convenience.

As the debate intensifies, the government now faces increasing calls to publicly explain the necessity for the proposed amendment, while legal bodies continue to insist that preserving public confidence in judicial independence must remain the overriding consideration.